The diaper aisle is packed with different choices, how should new parents decide which is best for their little one? If you’re deciding between Baby Dry vs Swaddlers, then you’re in the right place. We’re going to break down the pros and cons of both to help you choose and to know the difference between Baby Dry and Swaddlers.
If you are also thinking about trying Pampers Cruisers, check out this post where I break down the difference between Cruisers and Swaddlers.
(FYI: this post contains affiliate links. Meaning if you purchase anything through a link on this page, I receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.)
What is the difference between Baby Dry and Swaddlers?
A diaper is a diaper, right? What’s the big fuss about different brands or different styles? I mean… they all catch the pee and poop and get thrown in the garbage ASAP. Why does choosing the right one really matter? Do you really need worry about Pampers Baby Dry vs Swaddlers?
It turns out there can be pretty big differences between all the diapers out there on the market, and the different choices can also come with a big difference in price and/or quality. And just because something has a higher price tag doesn’t automatically mean it is better. In fact, lots of parents and babies are perfectly happy with store brand diapers.
On the other hand, some parents and babies have sensitive skin or allergies that require them to use a specific brand of diaper because all others mean rashes. To some degree, finding the perfect diaper for a lot of families is a bit of trial and error. But if you’ve narrowed it down to Pampers Baby Dry vs. Swaddlers, this guide will help you make that final call on which to go with.
The TDLR version on whether to pick Pampers Baby Dry vs Swaddlers:
Please check out all the additional info below, but if you want the quick and dirty version of which diapers win in the Baby Dry vs. Swaddlers battle then just read this next paragraph.
Pampers Baby Dry Overview
Need an all-around good diaper for your little one? One that you can use for months and months to come? something affordable, but still quality? Then Pampers Baby Dry might be the perfect fit for your little one.
They are affordable compared to some other Pampers diapers, and when it comes to Baby Dry vs. Swaddlers they are less expensive coming in at about $.26 per diaper vs. $.31 per diaper for Swaddlers.
Pampers Baby Dry Features
- Air Dry Channels
- 3 Layers of Absorbancy
- Wetness indicator
- Breathability
- Soft Cotton-like Feel
- All Around Stretchy Sides
Designed to keep baby dry
The name might be a hint. They’re called “Baby Dry” for a reason. The biggest features on these diapers is focused on containing wetness and keeping baby well… dry.
If you’ve been struggling with leaks and blowouts then it would definitely be worth giving Baby Dry a shot. All Pampers diapers claim to lock away wetness, including Swaddlers, but when it comes to Baby Dry vs Swaddlers, if keeping your baby dry is your number one priority over other features then definitely give this one a try.
Of course every parent wants to keep their baby dry and have diapers that do the job, but others like Swaddlers are also made to be extra soft and have features that newborns would really appreciate. So if you have an older baby that just seems to pee through everything, then you might be willing to get a diaper that’s not *quite* as soft, but packs a punch in the absorbancy department.
Dermatologically Tested and Hypo-allergenic
All Pampers have these same or similar ingredients and are tested to be safe for baby’s sensitive skin. Read more about what Pampers includes in their diapers here.
Affordable Price
One big different between Pampers Baby Dry vs Swaddlers is that Baby Dry diapers are cheaper than Swaddlers. It boils down to about a 5 cent difference per diaper. A nickel isn’t necessarily a ton of money, but if you add up all the nickelts for every diaper your baby goes through… it could add up!
Pampers Baby Dry Biggest Pros
The reviews from parents on Amazon are pretty incredible for the Baby Dry diapers. With tens of thousands of reviews, they get a whopping 4.8 out of 5 stars.
One of the biggest things parents rave about is the absorbancy. Many say they almost never have leaks, and the diapers are surprisingly thin and not too bulky even though they offer such awesome leak protection.
Pampers Baby Dry Biggest Cons
Most negative reviews say that these diapers don’t seem like the real Pampers Baby Dry on Amazon. That they are faulty or counterfeit. I suppose this is possible, but these reviews are not common and other parents have compared them to store-bought and found they are identical.
Besides that there are nearly no reviews that are really critical of the Baby Dry diapers. Some say they are better at holding in the pee than the poo, especially for newborns, while most have had no problems with blowouts.
Pampers Swaddlers Overview
Whether you have a newborn or an older baby, Pampers Swaddlers are a great choice. They are super soft,
While they are mostly designed for newborns with features like an umbilical cord notch, they work just as well for growing babies and even toddlers. Plus, they run from newborn up to size 7! So if you start out with them and love them, you won’t need to change or worry about Pampers Baby Dry vs Swaddlers after making this initial choice.
But one difference between Pampers Baby Dry vs Swaddlers is that Swaddlers are slightly more expensive. Newborn Baby Dry diapers run about $.26 per diaper, while the Swaddlers are $.31 per diaper. Only 5 cents difference, but when you add up all the diapers you’ll be buying for a baby it can add up. So if budget is an issue then Baby Dry might work better for you.
Pampers Swaddlers Features:
- Blankie soft
- BreatheFree Liner
- Soft stretchy sides
- Umbilical cord notch
- Dual leak guard barriers
- Lockaway channels
- Wetness indicator
- Hypoallergenic and no parabens or latex
Super soft diapers meant for newborn’s delicate skin
Since Pampers Swaddlers are made with newborns and little babies in mind (though they are perfect for older babies too!), they are made with material and a design that is extra soft.
The sides are stretchy allowing for freedom of movement and comfort, and Pampers calls them “blankie soft.” If you have a picky baby who really needs softness and comfort then these would be a great choice when considering Baby Dry vs Swaddlers.
Lockaway Channels and Dual Leak Guard for few leaks
Blowouts and wet baby clothes are no fun. You’ve already got so much on your plate as a new parent, you don’t want to deal with leaky diapers.
Pampers Swaddlers have multiple features to lock in wetness so your baby can stay as dry as possible, as long as possible. (Here’s to hoping that means longer stretches of sleep at night!)
Mid-range price
Pampers Swaddlers aren’t the cheapest diapers on the market, and not even the cheapest diapers from Pampers. However, they are fairly competitively priced, and are certainly not the most expensive out there.
If you want to go with the least expensive then Pampers Swaddlers aren’t for you, but if you can spring for a mid-range priced diaper, then these will work fine.
Dermatologically Tested and Hypo-allergenic
All Pampers have these same or similar ingredients and are tested to be safe for baby’s sensitive skin. Read more about what Pampers includes in their diapers here.
Pampers Swaddlers Biggest Pros:
The features on Pampers Swaddlers are perfect for all babies, but are especially well suited for newborns. From the umbilical cord notch to the softer than soft feel, tiny ones will love them.
But they go in sizes up to 7 for babies 41lbs or more! The large range of size means that if you and your baby fall in love with these diapers you won’t have to switch basically… ever!
Pampers Swaddlers Biggest Cons:
One thing to note about all Pampers diapers is they are scented. So if are looking for completely unscented diapers then the question of Pampers Baby Dry vs Swaddlers is kind of a moot one since both are scented.
Also, Pampers Swaddlers are not the *most* expensive diapers out there, but they aren’t the cheapest either. If you are on a tight budget then you might want to try something like the Up & Up brand at Target, which are also awesome diapers but easier on the wallet.
Frequently Asked Questions about Pampers Swaddlers and Cruisers
Which Is Better Baby Dry or Swaddlers?
Baby Dry vs Swaddlers might be a tough choice because both are excellent diapers with thousands of glowing reviews. The bottom line is if you want to save a few bucks go with Baby Dry, but if you prefer paying a little more for extra softness and features (especially for newborn) pick Swaddlers.
Which type of Pampers is best?
Pampers touts itself as the #1 brand recommended by pediatricians, and the vast majority of parents agree that they are a great brand with a great product. Each of their diapers have different pros and cons. Based on our research the best diaper totaly depends on your baby. For newborns Swaddlers are the best pick. If you have a toddler or baby on the go, then try Cruisers. But if you’re on a budget and want to pinch a few pennies, Baby Dry is the most affordable.
Do Pampers Baby Dry have wetness indicator?
Yes. Pampers Baby Dry has a wetness indicator.
Are Pampers Baby Dry scented?
Yes. According to Pampers: “We’ve asked parents all around the world which products they prefer for their babies and they’ve told us they prefer diapers with a soft, baby-fresh scent. The fragrance in Pampers is used at a very low level in each diaper and has been carefully selected and evaluated to be non-allergenic and non-irritating to the skin.”
